Monday, October 28, 2013

Santiago-Monteverde v. Pereira



As many readers of our Cooler e-mails and blog posts are aware, one of the hottest current topics in personal bankruptcy is the treatment of rent–stabilized leases in Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy cases. Earlier this month, the New York Times had an excellent front page article entitled “Widow's Bankruptcy Case Poses Risk to Rent-Stabilized Tenants.” The case is captioned Santiago-Monteverede v. Pereira and involves 79 year old Mrs. Mary Veronica Santiago-Monteverede, who has lived in a two bedroom rent stabilized apartment in the East Village for 50 years and is paying monthly rent of $703, while the market rate for the unit would be $2,000 to $2,500 per month.

Ms. Santiago-Monteverede filed Chapter 7 bankruptcy to discharge $23,000 of debt, none of which was owed to her landlord. Her landlord made an offer to purchase her lease from Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee John S. Pereira, which he accepted.  The sale of the lease was subsequently challenged by Ms. Santiago-Monteverde’s attorneys.  The U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York and the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York both ruled in favor of the Bankruptcy Trustee, and the case is now pending before the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, where oral arguments were held on September 23rd.

This is the first Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy rent–stabilized case to reach the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals. Please keep monitoring our Cooler e-mails and blog, and when the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals issues a decision and order, we will report on it. Again, debtors who live in apartments with rent–stabilized leases need to proceed with extreme caution in deciding whether to file for bankruptcy. Jim

No comments: